“Well, now, you asked them. Does that mean that they were expected to go?’: Master Narratives and Counter-Narratives in the Trial of Adnan Syed
Mots-clés :
narrative criminology, criminal trials, conversation analysis, tropesRésumé
A criminal trial in a traditional Western adversarial justice system is performed as a discursive battle of competing narratives between prosecution and defence. In the end, decisions by the judge and jury, while ostensibly premised on the strength of the evidence, rely in large part on the relative persuasive strength of the two stories – which one is more plausible? Commonsensical? Familiar? After exploring the positioning of narrative studies within the field of Criminology, this article will draw on ethnomethodology, talk-in-interaction, and narrative analysis to examine a trial that took place in the United States in 2000 – that of Adnan Syed. In order to appeal to cultural understandings shared by the American jury, trope stories were deployed by both sides. Prosecution told the story of Adnan Syed, a Jilted Muslim Lover, defending his honour after the victim broke up with him. Meanwhile, defence countered with a Star-Crossed-Lovers narrative, in which there was no motive for violence. I will argue that defence failed to deploy their story effectively and, in their attempts to counter the prosecution’s narrative, rather ended up reinforcing its terms. The triumph of the prosecution’s case may be found in the details of how the defence’s counter-narrative failed.
Références
Atkinson, J. M., & Drew, P. (1979). Order in Court: The Organisation of Verbal Interaction in Judicial Settings (P. Drew, Ed.) [Book]. Macmillan.
Barrera, D. J. S. (2019). Narrative Criminal Justice. International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice , 58, 35–43.
Bennett, W. L., & Feldman, M. S. (1981). Reconstructing Reality in the Courtroom (M. S. Feldman, Ed.) [Book]. Tavistock.
Bens, J. (2018a). Sentimentalising Persons and Things: Creating Normative Arrangements of Bodies through Courtroom Talk [Article]. Journal of Legal Anthropology, 2(1), 72–91. https://doi.org/10.3167/jla.2018.020105
Bens, J. (2018b). The courtroom as an affective arrangement: analysing atmospheres in courtroom ethnography [Article]. The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law, 50(3), 336–355. https://doi.org/10.1080/07329113.2018.1550313
Billig, M. (1985). Prejudice, categorization and particularization: From a perceptual to a rhetorical approach. European Journal of Social Psychology, 15(1), 79–103.
Burkhardt, A., & Nerlich, B. (2010). Introduction. In A. Burkhardt & B. Nerlich (Eds.), Tropical Truth(s): The Epistemology of Metaphor and other Tropes. De Gruyter.
Carlen, P. (1976). Magistrates’ Justice [Book]. M. Robertson.
Cicourel, A. V. (1976). The Social Organization of Juvenile Justice [Book]. Heinemann Educational.
Conley, J., & O’Barr, W. (1985). Litigant Satisfaction versus Legal Adequacy in Small Claims Court Narratives [Article]. Law and Society Review, 19(4), 661–702.
Czarniawska, B. (2004). Narratives in Social Science Research. SAGE Publications Ltd.
Dahlberg, L. (2009). Emotional tropes in the courtroom: On representation of affect and emotion in legal court proceedings [Article]. Nordic Theatre Studies, 21, 128–152.
Danblon, E. (2010). Persuasion: between trope and truth. In A. Burkhardt & B. Nerlich (Eds.), Tropical Truth(s): The Epistemology of Metaphor and other Tropes . De Gruyter.
Emerson, R. M. (1969). Judging Delinquents: Context and Process in Juvenile Court [Book]. Aldine Publishing.
Ewick, P., & Silbey, S. (1995). Subversive Stories and Hegemonic Tales: Toward a Sociology of Narrative [Article]. Law and Society Review, 29(2), 197–197. https://doi.org/10.2307/3054010
Felton Rosulek, L. (2014). Dueling discourses: the construction of reality in closing arguments [Book]. Oxford University Press.
Fielding, N. G. (2013). Lay people in court: The experience of defendants, eyewitnesses and victims [Article]. British Journal of Sociology, 64(2), 287–307. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-4446.12018
Garfinkel, H. (1967). Studies in Ethnomethodology [Book]. Polity Press.
Goodson, I. F., & Gill, S. R. (2011). The Narrative Turn in Social Research. Counterpoints, 386, 17–33.
Hall, M., & Rossmanith, K. (2016). Imposed Stories: Prisoner Self-narratives in the Criminal Justice System in New South Wales, Australia [Article]. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy, 5(1), 38–51. https://doi.org/10.5204/ijcjsd.v5i1.284
Halsey, M. (2017). Narrative Criminology. In A. Deckert & R. Sarre (Eds.), The Palgrave Handbook of Australian and New Zealand Criminology, Crime and Justice. Springer International Publishing.
Harris, A. (2007). Diverting and Abdicating Judicial Discretion: Cultural, Political, and Procedural Dynamics in California Juvenile Justice [Article]. Law & Society Review, 41(2), 387–428. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-5893.2007.00302.x
Hepburn, A., & Bolden, G. B. (2014). The Conversation Analytic Approach to Transcription. In J. Sidnell & T. Stivers (Eds.), The Handbook of Conversation Analysis (pp. 57–76). Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
Jackson, J. (2023). Rethinking the Orality/ Confrontation Paradigm in a World of Remote Evidence. The Criminal Law Review, 265(4), 265–285.
Koenig, S. (2014). Serial [Broadcast]. Serial Productions.
Lakoff, G., & Johnson, M. (1980). Metaphors We Live By (2nd ed.). University of Chicago Press.
Lakoff, G., & Johnson, M. (2003). Metaphors we live by (M. Johnson, Ed.; [New editi) [Book]. University of Chicago Press.
Maruna, S., & Liem, M. (2020). Where Is This Story Going? A Critical Analysis of the Emerging Field of Narrative Criminology. Annual Review of Criminology, 4(1), 125–146.
Matoesian, G. M. (1993). Reproducing Rape: Domination through Talk in the Courtroom [Book]. Polity Press.
Matoesian, G. M. (2001). Law and the Language of Identity: Discourse in the William Kennedy Smith Rape Trial. Oxford University Press.
McKendy, J. P. (2006). ‘I’m very careful about that’: narrative and agency of men in prison [Article]. Discourse & Society, 17(4), 473–502. https://doi.org/10.1177/0957926506063128
Nietzsche, F. (1873). On Truth and Lies in a Nonmoral Sense. In K. A. Pearson & D. Large (Eds.), The Nietzsche Reader. Blackwell.
Offit, A. (2019). Storied Justice: The Narrative Strategies of U.S. Federal Prosecutors. In J. Fleetwood, L. Presser, S. Sandberg, & T. Ugelvik (Eds.), The Emerald Handbook of Narrative Criminology (pp. 45–62). Emerald Publishing Limited .
Paik, L. (2011). Discretionary Justice Looking Inside a Juvenile Drug Court [Book]. Rutgers University Press.
Pemberton, A., Aarten, P., & Mulder, E. (2018). Stories as Property: Narrative ownership as a key concept in victims’ experiences with criminal justice [Article]. Criminology and Criminal Justice, 19(4), 404–420. https://doi.org/10.1177/1748895818778320
Piccotti, T., & Chang, R. (2023, March 28). Adnan Syed: A Complete Timeline of His Trial, Appeal, Release, and the Murder of Hae Min Lee. Biography.Com. https://www.biography.com/crime/adnan-syed-hae-min-lee-timeline-facts
Polkinghorne, D. E. (1988). Narrative Knowing and the Human Sciences. State University of New York Press.
Pomerantz, A., & Atkinson, J. (1984). Ethnomethodology, conversation analysis and the study of courtroom interaction. In D. J. Muller, D. E. Blackman, & A. J. Chapman (Eds.), Topics in Psychology and Law (pp. 283–294). John Wiley & Sons.
Prasad, R., Nguyen, L., Schwartz, R., & Makhoul, J. (2002). Automatic transcription of courtroom speech. 7th International Conference on Spoken Language Processing.
Presser, L. (2009). The Narratives of Offenders. Theoretical Criminology, 13(2), 177–200.
Presser, L. (2016). Criminology and the narrative turn [Article]. Crime, Media, Culture: An International Journal, 12(2), 137–151. https://doi.org/10.1177/1741659015626203
Prudente, T. (2019, March 8). Adnan Syed Case: Maryland High Court Reinstates ‘Serial’ Subject’s Conviction. The Baltimore Sun. https://www.baltimoresun.com/news/crime/bs-md-ci-syed-appeal-20190222-story.html
Rock, P. (1991). Witnesses and Space in a Crown Court [Article]. British Journal of Criminology, 31(3), 266–279. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordjournals.bjc.a048116
Roemer, M. (1997). Telling Stories: Postmodernism and the Invalidation of Traditional Narrative. Rowman & Littlefield.
Rosch, E. (1978). Principles of Categorization. In E. Rosch & B. B. Lloyd (Eds.), Cognition and Categorization. Erlbaum Associates New York: Distributed by Halsted Press.
Saldaña, J. (2021). The coding manual for qualitative researchers (Fourth edition.) [Book]. SAGE.
Sandberg, S. (2016). The importance of stories untold: Life-story, event-story and trope [Article]. Crime, Media, Culture: An International Journal, 12(2), 153–171. https://doi.org/10.1177/1741659016639355
Sandberg, S., & Ugelvik, T. (2016). The past, present, and future of narrative criminology: A review and an invitation [Article]. Crime, Media, Culture: An International Journal, 12(2), 129–136. https://doi.org/10.1177/1741659016663558
Sidnell, J., & Stivers, T. (Eds.). (2014). The Handbook of Conversation Analysis. (2nd ed..) [Book]. Wiley Blackwell.
The Undisclosed Wiki. (n.d.). Official Court Transcripts of Adnan Syed’s First and Second Trials in 1999 and 2000. The Undisclosed Wiki. Retrieved February 11, 2024, from https://www.adnansyedwiki.com/trials/
Witte, B. (2022, September 15). “Serial” case: Prosecutors move to vacate Syed’s conviction. AP News. https://apnews.com/article/adnan-syed-conviction-baltimore-prosecutors-c6ee72fa85c79c1bdf7b5486ea762010
Téléchargements
Publié-e
Comment citer
Numéro
Rubrique
Licence
Copyright for articles published in Narrative Works is retained by the author(s), with first publication rights granted to Narrative Works. By virtue of their appearance in this open access journal, articles are free to use, with proper attribution, in educational and other non-commercial settings.
