Skip to main navigation menu Skip to main content Skip to site footer

Articles

Volume 35, Number 1 (2010)

The Stone Diaries as an “Apocryphal Journal”

Submitted
September 29, 2010
Published
2010-09-01

Abstract

In The Stone Diaries (1993), Carol Shields interrogates the conventions of autobiography and its ability to represent the life of an ordinary woman. A striking feature of the text is its sudden and sometimes disconcerting shifts in narrative voice from first to third. From this evidence, it seems that it is Judith Downing, Daisy Goodwill’s eldest granddaughter, who writes Daisy’s life story, in collaboration with various family members,. This reading of the narrative as an apocryphal history, or “apocryphal journal” (Stone 118), is supported by archival evidence, by Shields’s own commentary, and by textual analysis. Influenced by postmodernist revisionist critiques of historiography and taking the form of a meta-autobiography, The Stone Diaries presents a sophisticated and complex feminist critique of dominant discourses such as autobiography, and it anticipates recent theoretical directions in women’s life writing and autobiography studies.